Black Suit or Charcoal Suit, which one to choose?
Four Reasons Why Your Black Suit Sucks, and Charcoal is Superior
As your online suit guide, I am going to give you four reasons why Black suits suck, and why Charcoal is the better option.
Here we go!
'
Charcoal Versus Footwear
One of the biggest advantages of Charcoal is its versatility, especially when it comes to footwear. Brown shoes? Works. Black shoes? Works. Burgundy? Probably works too. Charcoal gives you options which is always a good thing when you're trying to build a wardrobe that doesn't put people to sleep, or click a button to wipe people’s memory (That's a “Men and Black” reference, for all the youth!)
Meanwhile, the Black suit and Black shoe combination has been on life support for too long, and it’s time to pull the plug.
In the year of our icon, Beyoncé 2026? BORING!
Leave it in 1997. Trust me.
Charcoal Doesn't Need a Funeral to Make Sense
Your Charcoal suit would look amazing at the funeral. More importantly, unlike a Black suit, Charcoal doesn’t feel trapped by the occasion. Sure, it can handle a funeral with dignity and respect, but it won’t sit in your closet collecting dust, just waiting for the Grim Reaper to come knocking. See, Charcoal understands versatility. Black, on the other hand... Not so much.
Let’s have a moment of realness, and let me hold your hand as I tell you this: You guys can
barely ever get your shades of Black correctly. The jacket is one Black, the trousers are another Black, the shoes are fighting for their lives trying to match, and somehow the belt showed up to the party with an even deeper shade of Black. It looks tacky.
There’s a better way to do Black on Black… on Black. Maybe go for some suspenders instead of that uninspired leather belt. Even a front pleat for some vintage vibes.
Charcoal, however, gives you all the formality of Black without forcing you into a never-ending battle of matching shades. Your Charcoal suit can move beautifully from the workplace to a dinner reservation. It’s one of the few shades that can be serious when it needs to be and stylish when you want it to be.
Charcoal is a Year-Round Color when Styled Correctly
Darker colors are tricky in the summertime, and unless we’re talking about fresco or tropical wool, Charcoal isn’t an exception during the hottest months of summer. BUT… People often underestimate how adaptable Charcoal actually is. With a few changes in styling, the same suit that carried you through a treacherous winter can look perfectly at home in the spring and fall months.
In the warmer months, you may want to swap out the heavier accessories for something softer, introduce some color, and be a little less structured with styling. Ditch the tie, leave the top unbuttoned, and suddenly your Charcoal suit takes on an entirely different personality.
In the fall, Charcoal pairs well with richer textures and seasonal colors. Come winter, it settles right back into its comfort zone. And that’s why your Black suit sucks and Charcoal is supreme; Black is easy to wear and usually the laziest option. A few small changes and the same suit can carry you through most of the year.
Very few suit colors transition between seasons as effortlessly as Charcoal…
And when I say “Very few,” I mean especially not your Black suit.
Charcoal Doesn’t Make You Look Like the Help
You can wear Charcoal without looking like a butler or a funeral director, and I’m not even sure that they still wear Black suits.
One of the biggest problems with Black suits is that they start to look less like a style choice and more like a uniform. Throw in a white shirt, a black tie, and those black shoes (none of the shades match—by the way) and suddenly people are wondering if you’re about to valet their car or seat them at their table for two.
The difference is that Charcoal has depth. Charcoal has personality, and it demands the space to define its own purpose. And what I mean by that is this: Charcoal is intentional and Black often is the uncreative choice.
Charcoal has infinitely more range than a Black suit and because it’s in the grey family, it is neutral. In other words, what matches Black also matches Charcoal. However, you’ll get more out of your Charcoal, and that’s what makes it such a powerful color.
In Summation
Charcoal simply has more range. It works with more shoes, more occasions, and more seasons while giving you all the authority of a darker suit without looking like you're reporting for duty. If you're choosing between Black and Charcoal, the answer is simple. And if you’re interested in purchasing your own Charcoal Suit, click here.
Check out our all-custom men's suit collection here
